2008-09 Trophy Winners For Red Wings
The NHL blogs here at SBNation are throwing out what players on their teams would win various NHL trophies if they were isolated to just their own players (see the full list). The Red Wings have an interesting challenge: they're actual nominees for some of these trophies.
Without further ado:
Calder (Rookie): Johann Ericsson. Find a player on the Red Wings that meets the requirements for the Calder: under 26 years old, no more than 25 games in a previous season, no more than 6 games in any two previous seasons. According to my reading of the roster, that leaves exactly Johann Ericsson.
Sometimes, you win just by being the only one left.
Vezina (Goaltender): Ty Conklin. Yes, I know that Chris Osgood is the main goaltender for the playoffs. Still, I get a fear somehow that we're seeing the "old" Chris Osgood: the one that gives up the bad goals at the worst time.
For what it's worth, Conklin has put up plenty of quality starts. He's come in in relief on a couple of occasions and done a fine mop-up job. I think he's overperformed this year, and for that, I'd give him the nod over Osgood.
Norris (Defenseman): Nicklas Lidstrom. Because this is obvious, I want to throw out a thought-starter. What would have happened had there been no Steve Yzerman? What if Lidstrom had come to this team in 1991 without Yzerman having become a standard on the franchise in his eight years? Would we be looking now at this franchise about Lidstrom in the same way as we looked at it near the end of Yzerman's run?
I don't think we would. I think Lidstrom learned from the proverbial master with Yzerman in the locker room. Which is a darn shame. I'd like to see Lidstrom stick around for another 6 to 8 years, if only to have time to burnish his legend to the level Yzerman did around here.
Selke (Defensive Forward): Pavel Datsyuk. A three-horse race between Datsyuk, Marian Hossa, and Henrik Zetterberg, I give the edge to Datsyuk for two reasons: an impressive 56.8% faceoff percentage, a balanced performance both at home and away (Hossa, for instance, is +22 at home but only +3 on the road), and a stunning 88 takeaways (leading all forwards; second place is Zetterberg with 39).
He's grown into this role over the past 4 years. You can see him taking the leadership role after Lidstrom. Which leads me to...
Hart (MVP): Datsyuk. This kills me, because I've always felt that there's been a sense that Lidstrom never gets considered for an overall MVP because of his 6 Norris Trophies. This gets into a larger perspective of the V in MVP. Lidstrom shows leadership and value throughout this season. Hossa, who said he wanted a better shot at the Cup (despite being in the Cup finals last year), has bought into the system to a level that I don't think anyone thought he would.
This year, however, I've developed a confidence in Datsyuk that I didn't have in him before. This is not to say that I've lost confidence in anyone else in the winged wheel. This week's SI features an article on Datsyuk as a legit Hart candidate, and it goes into how much he's become a fixture in the locker room and in the heart and minds.
The final tiebreaker for me is this: do I think the Wings have a chance to repeat if this player is unable to perform in the playoffs? If Datsyuk disappered come one week from today, I think that chance disappears. He's my MVP.
Share your thoughts below.
0 recs |
7 comments
|
Comments
My Two Cents
I would have picked Ville Leino over Ericsson as the Calder. Ericsson came to my mind first, but Leino’s play over that span of 13 games was great and I can’t wait to see him this postseason. That being said, the Wings don’t really have one rookie who played more than Ericsson’s 16 games so it’s not like there is one clear cut winner or a DRW rookie who has a shot at the actual Calder.
Hart was the other one up for debate in my mind. Lidstrom does usually get skipped over, but I didn’t view him as a frontrunner this year. Last year, most certainly. I actually would pick Marian Hossa, but Datsyuk is obviously a great choice as well. Hossa has just been such a clutch player for us that I have no doubt we would not be #2 in the conference without him in the lineup. Again, you could say that about Datsyuk as well. I guess we’re pretty lucky that we have more than just one great player to consider!
by Christy on Apr 7, 2009 3:05 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
On Leino v Ericsson
You’re right. When I was writing up the list, I was going off the active roster to look and see who was eligible, and Leino wasn’t on it, which is why I didn’t think of him. And, since he turns 26 in October, he’ll be ineligible next year.
In fact, I can’t even remember the last reasonable candidate for the Calder to come from Detroit. I know no Red Wing has won since Roger Crozier in 1964-65.
by joehass on Apr 7, 2009 5:36 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Zetterberg
Zetterberg finished second in Calder voting to Barret Jackman in 02-03. He had 22g and 22a. I’d say he was very reasonable. Too bad Leino’s ineligible next year.
by PattyWhoa on Apr 9, 2009 3:15 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Are you kidding??
Hey joehass,
There’s a guy I remember had 87 points his rookie year and finished 2nd in Calder voting . He was also the youngest player selected to an all-star team at the time. You’ve probably heard of him.
STEVE YZERMAN
by Wingsparky on Apr 10, 2009 10:16 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Ehh.
After giving it more thought, your Datsyuk pick for Hart was the right call. So you can all ignore my Hossa for Hart comments. :)
by Christy on Apr 7, 2009 3:36 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Have to agree..
Good reasoning and logic. No complaints here. Well done!
by motownchollis on Apr 7, 2009 3:45 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Good Picks
Good picks on these. I like Datsyuk for Hart. I know this post was just on the RW but as far as the league goes, one thing a lot of people have overlooked in comparison to Malkin, Ovechkin, Crosby is his /-, face-off %, and time on ice. Datsyuk averages about 19 mins a game while the other three average 22 per game. Thats a big difference in ice time and the fact that he has comparable numbers says a lot.
Good picks though. Maybe someday soon we’ll see Kronwall with his name next to Norris Trophy :)
http://mrnorristrophy.blogspot.com
by Casey Richey on Apr 8, 2009 1:34 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs

by 


















