Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Kobe Bryant Will Never Top Michael Jordan

What if Mo says "no"?

Photo

In Mike Modano's last home game as a Dallas star, he gave the crowd a storybook ending. Modano assisted on the first goal, scored the game-tying goal with under two minutes to play in the game and scored the decisive goal in the shootout on Jonas Hiller. Everything appeared as if it were the proper ending fro Modano's NHL career the next game as he played his final game in a Dallas Stars jersey in the state of Minnesota, everything coming full circle. 

But Mo's not done yet, and nor should he be. He's got gas left in the tank, goals yet to be scored and players yet to mentor. 

As soon as the Stars announced they would not pursue a contract for Modano, notions of him coming back to play for the hometown team in Detroit let loose. Much to the dismay of Stars fans everywhere, those notions started to become more of a reality as the Red Wings began to seriously court Modano for his services. Detroit fans began to change they're sentences from "if we get Modano..." to "when we get Modano..." while worrying over what number Mo would wear in Detroit.

All of that is starting to look a little less secure at the moment though as two new teams have emerged in the Mike Modano sweepstakes. Reports are surfacing that both the San Jose Sharks and the Minnesota Wild are in the mix for Modano. Would he take those offers over a stint in Detroit? 

Minnesota offers Modano a bit of nostalgia as he would go back to the state where he played his first four years and began the path to become the highest scoring American born player in NHL history. Minnesota is in the worst shape of the three candidates in terms of hopes for getting another ring as there's no core in place that emerges as a potential playoff contender. Mikko Koivu, Andrew Brunette and Guillaume Latendresse are the biggest assets Minnesota has but is it enough for Modano to consider them for any other reason than going back to where it started?

San Jose, however, offers him practically the same chance for success and another shot at the Stanley Cup that Detroit would. San Jose has a solid lineup despite replacing Evgeni Nabokov and having Rob Blake retire. Modano has no emotional or loyalty tie to San Jose like that of Minnesota or Detroit so that might be something that he considers in when it comes down to making the decision. 

Now as Modano heads towards a decision he has more to consider than originally thought. There's also still a chance that Modano could retire but for our purposes we'll assume he will pursue another year in the NHL considering his inclination to continue talking to teams. If Modano says "no", where do the Red Wings go from there? 

They could easily stay within their own organization to fill that roster spot that Modano would have filled and that would keep either Miller or Draper in the line-up, assuming Abdelkader and Helm re-sign. They could go outside of the organization and consider a guy like Arron Asham or Evgeny Artyukhin to fill that grinder/tough-guy forward position that they are looking for. Or, they could use the money to secure a 6th/7th defenseman and keep a bit of cap space heading into the season.

If Modano heads for retirement or decides to play for a team other than the Red Wings, what would you do as GM Ken Holland?

Comment 15 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Winging It In Motown

Morning Skate: Star Power

Jan 2012 by JeffHancock41 - 26 comments

Mike Modano Retires

Sep 2011 by Amerinadian - 7 comments

Comments

Display:

I like the idea of going after Asham, if for no other reason than his hair is awesome. I want Modano, but only if we can get him without having to give up Helm. He’s my favorite Red Wing right now.

by Ian Merrifield on Jul 10, 2010 6:02 PM CDT reply actions  

If I couldn’t pick up Madono, I would be looking at Kyle Wellwood.

by RVB on Jul 10, 2010 6:22 PM CDT reply actions  

I'd be looking at him too.

If you don’t keep an eye on him he steals your cookies when you aren’t paying attention.

"While there's life, there's hope." --Cicero
Science nerd and proud of it!

by Baroque on Jul 11, 2010 12:12 AM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

If Mo says no

bring in Asham or Exelby.

In life, a man is either the hammer or the anvil. Ndamukong Suh is both

by JazzyBBP on Jul 10, 2010 9:28 PM CDT reply actions  

If he decides to go for another team

I’d lose a bit of respect for him on being hypocritical to when he said Detroit or Retirement. (Oh and if it happens to be San Jose too, his wife probably had a role in it. (“Honey, but Michigan is so cold! And San Jose is closer for me to work on my tan and Hollywood!” >.<) )

If he retires, I’d be disappointed yet it would be much more fitting and relieving to Stars fans. For some Stars fans though, San Jose would be worse then Detroit considering that they’re a divisional rival. Stars fans would probably be more consented with Retirement or Minnesota, where Modano would only be there to please the former North Stars fans but no chance at a Stanley Cup really.

Oh and guys, no matter if Modano signs or not Holland said Abby and Helm will be playing for the Wings one way or another. That means if Modano asks for money price that would threaten any chance of Helm and/or Abby signing he’ll reject it.

by SonicMario(RW) on Jul 10, 2010 9:42 PM CDT reply actions  

To be fair, when he said Detroit or retirement, those were his only two options. I don’t think San Jose had taken a run at him at that point.

by westspec on Jul 11, 2010 12:11 PM CDT up reply actions  

He may have contacted San Jose himself at some point – but Minnesota certainly didn’t show any interest until afterwards. But if neither the Wild or the Sharks reciprocated his interest then Detroit and retirement would have remained his only two options.

"While there's life, there's hope." --Cicero
Science nerd and proud of it!

by Baroque on Jul 11, 2010 3:08 PM CDT up reply actions  

I believe though

That Modano would not just miss the oppurtunity to play for a contender. The Sharks are real good, but their the Sharks. I’m not saying the Wings could promise one more for Mo but he should look at our success, the Stars play well enough against the Sharks but the Stars have been beat by the Wings twice in the Playoffs (2008, 1998 interestingly that they were 10 years apart and both in the WCF and in both of those years the Wings won the Cup). I’ll eat my words if he ends up going to San Jose or Minnesota. I’m not exactly saying the Wings are the right choice either, but I’m postive if he’s still playing the Wings will be his choice.

P.S. It would betray me to think he’d go somewhere else after being treated to a table with the management AND watch a Tigers game (I personally had thought that if the Tigers won that game he would sign, and win they did with a dramatic Home Run. Funny, I was basing a Baseball game to be the decison for a Hockey signing)

by SonicMario(RW) on Jul 11, 2010 6:11 PM CDT up reply actions  

I’d sign Abdelkader and Helm and maybe look around for a veteran defenseman. Which might be an area of need instead of want. :)

"While there's life, there's hope." --Cicero
Science nerd and proud of it!

by Baroque on Jul 11, 2010 12:13 AM CDT reply actions  

Another Farve Fiasco...

Getting tired of all the drama surrounding Mondano. If the guy can’t make up his mind sign Abdelkader and Helm, pick up Asham and move along. This is dragging out way too long.

by Graywolf on Jul 11, 2010 6:52 AM CDT reply actions  

12 days is not “way too long”.

This isn’t Rob Medermeyer we’re talking about.

by Robocop on Jul 12, 2010 8:39 AM CDT up reply actions  

Guerin

We should make a run at Billy Guerin

by westspec on Jul 11, 2010 12:10 PM CDT reply actions  

Modano should be a Wing

Modano should just sign with Detroit and come home and let his close family and friends come and watch him play his final season instead of just a handful of games when the Stars/North Stars visited Joe Louis. Once Again San Jose stealin our ideas to try and be successful wish the state of California would just sink already. If Modano doesnt come to Detroit Id say going for a guy like Asham or Exelby…both pretty tough guys to play against who grind it out in the corners with a pretty nasty edge when needed.

by Jimbo5203 on Jul 11, 2010 7:42 PM CDT reply actions  

Modano

The Wing fans would love Modano as a Wing and he would love the special attention. He should consider that. However, he is taking too long to decide. Give him to Friday to make up his mind or tell him to stick it and get someone else not so old.

by papa1 on Jul 14, 2010 11:15 AM CDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Detroit Red Wings.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Reasons why the 2011-12 Detroit Red Wings season was great

Recent FanPosts

De_small
Should we Re-sign Abby? Am I the only one?
Small
Parise vs Suter
Small
What's next on Defense?
Small
More Thoughts on What Went Wrong
Small
Corey Perry? Strange coincidence
Small
Anyone else getting scared of the worst-case-scenario?
Epic_sax_guy_plz_by_epicsaxguyplz-d31pmuj_small
Great Moments in St. Louis Sports History
Small
Looking beyond next year...
Epic_sax_guy_plz_by_epicsaxguyplz-d31pmuj_small
Other Recent Personal Bests

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


The Gentlemen

Images_small J.J. from Kansas

Simpsonsabbey_small Amerinadian

Dsc07546_small JeffHancock41

Editor

Jabdelkadercamp08_small stripe

Author

Small Robocop

Photochop Guru

Whiteknight_small Josh Howard