Cancel the Parade: Wings Lose to Penguins 3-2
It's so hard to know how to react to a pre-season loss. Do you shrug it off as a nothing game and think to yourself "it's just an exhibition game and doesn't count"? Do you get frothy as you wonder how the hell "insert non-roster player's name here" could have gotten a tryout, let alone a contract with an NHL team?
Me, I like to look at the positives while mentioning the negatives. Tonight, there were far more positives to take away from the Red Wings' 3-2 loss to the Penguins than negatives, but as with any game, there's room for improvement.
If you believe the Penguins' announcers (who the bulk of us outside Detroit were lucky to be blessed with), then Evgeni Malkin was just too much man for the Red Wings tonight. While we think they may have over-stated how well he played (I'll freely admit he was probably the best player on the ice tonight), there's no question that he seems to have recovered very nicely from his knee injuries and should give the Penguins one-half of their offensive duo while Crosby nurses the boo-boo in his head.
So were the Wings simply dominated by one man? Follow the jump to take a look.
While the Wings were unable to come back after finding themselves down 3-1 after the second, there were a number of good things that happened in this game.
- Niklas Kronwall and Brad Stuart were both very active in the offensive zone. Kronwall in particular was pinching a lot, but was doing so smartly. It's a little early to see whether this is a new wrinkle in the Wings' offense or if they were just reacting to their opponent.
- Drew Miller and Fabian Brunnstrom both took big steps forward in asserting their spots in the lineup. Miller was charging the net early in the first and in the second, and was trying to create offense. Brunnstrom was all over the ice tonight, making smart passes and using his size to get open and drive the net.
- The Jan Mursak - Tomas Tatar - Chris Conner line was good, especially Mursak. I had forgotten how fast Mursak is, and with Tatar and Conner they were buzzing all around the Pens' zone. Considering this was the first game they played together, the potential for good chemistry appeared to be there, particularly between Mursak and Tatar.
- Jimmy Howard had a tough game. The first goal was one he should have had, and although the goal by Malkin was a nice play, that's 2 short-side goals in one game. There was also a post on the same side, and it's clear that Jimmy has some work still to do. On the flip side, Joey MacDonald came in and played very well, shutting down the Pens in the third period.
- Pavel Datsyuk seems to be in mid-season form already. He was all over the ice, making Pittsburgh players look silly, and his pass to Kronwall to set up the first Wings' goal was something I'd expect to see in January, not September. I'm teasing right here, but one of my BOLD PREDICTIONS (coming soon) is going to be about Dats. Also, his tribute to Ruslan Salei by wearing #24 makes even my Grinch-heart melt a little.
So that's it. It was the first pre-season game, so let's remember to keep our pitchforks and torches in the shed where they belong, at least until November. Tomorrow, the Wings head to London, Ontario for a date with the Philadelphia Flyers, who may be hearing from new disciplinarian Brendan Shanahan after a Joey Shelley hit on Darryl Boyce. We'll look into whether the game is televised. See you tomorrow!
22 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Tomorrow's game
is in London, ON…not at JLA.
I saw that
I’ll update the post. Thanks!
by Amerinadian on Sep 21, 2011 10:21 PM CDT up reply actions
Stuart seemed to struggle with the matchup at times
but he’ll round into form. If I had to pick around the bottom of the lineup after having seen only half the Wings compete in one game, I was most impressed with Miller and Mursak. I liked Conner’s hustle and I like that Brunnstrom has the skills. Tatar needs a bit more work, but he’s come along nicely.
Defensively, Exelby was noticeable in a bad way while Commodore looked calm and impressive.
Howard absolutely has to play better.
Malkin was simply playing at a different level from everybody else. He gave it more effort and that really showed in the fact that he has so much talent anyway.
by J.J. from Kansas on Sep 21, 2011 10:16 PM CDT reply actions
Datsyuk and Malkin showed that they are in a class of their own in comparison to every other player on the ice.
by Amerinadian on Sep 21, 2011 10:22 PM CDT up reply actions
Agreed, Datsyuk and Malkin clearly were head and shoulders above the rest.
Can’t judge too much in a pre-season, but the individual performances are something. I was impressed by a number of young Red Wings and Penguins (like Tartar, Morrow, Mursak, etc).
It was easy to see the NHL caliber guys like Holmstrom, Fleury, Kunitz, Stuart, Letang and Kronwall play…They were clearly more comfortable and looked like they belonged. Which is exactly what you’d expect.
All in all, I don’t think there were any injuries, and everyone got a little more experience and a chance to face a guy in a different color jersey. So it’s a success, regardless of the score.
"You come at the King, you best not miss."
by Hooks Orpik on Sep 21, 2011 11:41 PM CDT up reply actions
Exactly
I’m more concerned about what guys like Brunnstrom, Mursak and Emmerton do because they are the ones playing for roster spots. The NHL guys are simply trying to stay healthy and get back in game shape.
It pains me to say this, but I was really impressed by the Pens announcers. I love Ken and Mickey, but they are huge homers compared to the guys doing the game last night. We made it through at least the first period before I even started to suspect that they were not national TV announcers. Even when Cleary boarded the Pens player, they were like, “There’s your welcome to the NHL, rookie”
Until Crosby returns...
I’d say that they’re the two best in the league (and the world)
I will not cancel my parade!
Hockey season is here.. FINALLY!!! That’s worth at least a parade in itself.
It’s like I’ve been deprived of my favorite drug ( Hockey is my only drug) for what seems like ages.Then the first little hit comes again and the rush is bigger, the excitement stronger, the high more thrilling that I remembered. No more trying to find other things I care about as much as hockey, just to try to pass the time and pretending I’m not rocking back and forth in the corner mumbling to myself and drooling on my favorite jersey fashioning a shiny new tin foil hat…But I digress (just a little).
by SlapshotGoal on Sep 21, 2011 11:43 PM CDT reply actions 2 recs
A few quick thoughts
1. Datsyuk looked like he was playing at 1/2 speed and intensity, and he looked leagues superior than everyone else not wearing #71. It seemed like he flubbed a few moves that he could normally make look easy, just brushing off some rust I assume.
2. Kronwall has swagger. He looked very confident. I would love to know what his shooting percentage is in the high slot, he is deadly accurate. 50 points should be the minimum expectation this year.
3. The kids looked impressive. Mursak let his offensive game shine, and I think there is definately something there. Tatar hounds the puck, skates like a bulldog, and has sweet hands and instincts. Smith looked extremely promising, but he needs to mature defensively. He did a lot of pinching like a young Kronner. He could probably step into the nhl and do fine, but his game would be exploited. One more year in GR, I assume.
4. Brunnstrom is very skilled, he was definately trying to earn a contract and I think he will, 2-way and a few call-ups. Hopefully he tries to prove himself in the A and is productive.
5. Howard is very lax and rusty. I doubt he plays that way October 7th. No need to worry yet. He has never been very solid in the preseason.
6. Hudler looked very solid. He looked faster, stronger, and a lot more confident. If he continues that way I’d be happy with Hudler-D-Cleary on opening night. (Cleary had a strong game as well).
by PavelsBabbles on Sep 22, 2011 6:52 AM CDT via mobile reply actions 1 recs
Hudler
He almost looked like a different player. The small bit I saw was good.
Get your Al the Octopus
byjenniferleigh.etsy.com/
He's a small guy
and he’s got a ton of speed and works like a dog out there. Unfortunately, I think his offensive upside is much lower than the other guys we have fighting for a spot, and considering he’d be a 5’6" guy trying to get a role on the checking line, I’m not sure he’ll play for the Wings much this year.
True
He did look very confident and comfortable on the PK.
Of course, Drew Miller had a PK shift where he looked like he was captaining the whole thing.
by J.J. from Kansas on Sep 22, 2011 7:59 AM CDT up reply actions
The kids
Hudler did look like he had an extra step in his stride, he looked more confident than usual, so that’s a very promising sign. Cleary played well, despite getting that 5min major (it was also the guy’s fault for turning his back to Cleary KNOWING he was coming).
Smith and (can’t believe I’m saying this) Pyett impressed me a bit. They both made unwise passes at times, but overall their play was solid. Smith looks like an NHL d-man to me with very high potential.
Brunnstrom is a big body and I liked his speed, but he was trying to be far too fancy (he flubbed a breakaway and tried a move that shouldn’t be attempted in-game), and he’d stop moving his legs after he’d get hit and would give up on the puck too easily.
Mursak used his speed and size very well last night, protecting the puck and making good passes. From the little I saw of Emmerton, I’d say Mursak will beat him out of a spot.
I can’t wait to see more of Tatar on a good line, I know he’s got a good shot. The three prospects I’m most excited (all with a ton of skill) about are Tatar, Nyquist and Jurco.
Iron-hook
Don’t forget about Calle Jarnkrok.
by PavelsBabbles on Sep 22, 2011 8:44 AM CDT via mobile up reply actions
I really have to disagree on Smith. He did not seem like an NHL-ready dman to me. He was caught out of position several times (how many 2-on-1s did Commodore defend?), made some really odd waist level breakout passes, and passed the puck directly to the Pens several times.
Pyett seemed ok, but didn’t stand out at all. Commodore looked solid enough, but again didn’t stand out a lot.
To answer the question of “were the Wings simply dominated by one man?” The answer is definitely yes, Jimmy Howard completely crushed us. He let up 2 goals that hit him in the chest, and 1 where he cheated off his short side really badly.
Hudler I thought looked good, and almost had one. It was good to see him take the puck in and just shoot it. He’s got a good shot and needs to use it.
Brunstrom I want to like, but he didn’t really stand out to me. Scoring on his breakaway would’ve been nice. Mursak and Tatar are going to bring us a lot more speed. I liked that Tatar when out and hit someone after he got leveled by Kunitz. Good to see him get fired up rather than back off.
I know it is only preseason but...
between Amway and now losing a game, your season is doomed. I am truly sorry. tee-hee
SCH unofficial moderator ~ Thanks ahnfire
Hey now
we lost a close game to one of the East’s best teams. Didn’t your guys drop a 5-1 decision against the Flames?
by J.J. from Kansas on Sep 22, 2011 9:30 AM CDT up reply actions
We split games with them
It just so happens that they played most of their veterans in Calgary against a slightly better than AHL caliber Canuck team.
SCH unofficial moderator ~ Thanks ahnfire
I liked Commodore & Pyett on the D side of life
Mursak was impressive – that whole line was impressive all night too

by 
















