CSSI Analysis: Red Wings 3 - Blues 1
Monday night was an absolute playoff mentality game as much as November 26th against Boston or January 8th against Chicago. Once again, the Wings showed the kind of determination and composure it takes to win games like that as they drowned the Blues and won a 3-1 game that maybe wasn't even that close.
St. Louis earned one power play on the night and the Wings' PK stopped them handily. On the other side of the ledger, Detroit went 2-for-5 with the man advantage. It should be considered 2/4 though, as the fifth power play was 1.5 seconds long to end the game. The two teams tied the first period with 8 shots apiece, but Detroit pulled away to a 28-22 advantage by the end.
CSSI Methodology Explanation here
Goalie Ratings
Jimmy Howard definitely won the head-to-head contest, despite facing fewer shots. The Blues got several very good opportunities at key times and Howard managed to make three or four very big saves. He also showed he wasn't going to take people running him by smacking David Backes around a bit, which got a good laugh out of people who enjoy badasses doing badass things. I can safely say that without Howard, this game might go differently. Overall, I'd give Howard a +2.5 rating.
Scoring and plus/minus analysis after the jump
The Goals
1st Period 09:12 - St. Louis Goal: Scott Nichol (wrist shot) from BJ Crombeen and Chris Porter
The Blues get on the board first off a bad line change. The Blues dump it in to the corner away from the benches and move in to forecheck. Ericsson is first on it and he passes it short to Cleary, who goes up the boards to Miller. Miller gets pressured by Roman Polak and is forced to dump the puck out of the zone in a hail Mary attempt to Abdelkader at the opposite blue line. As this happens, Ericsson, Miller, and Stuart change behind the play. Kris Russell intercepts the dump and turns it back up ice where it gets past Cleary skating up ice to help. This sends Chris Porter into the zone on a 3-on-1 as only Niklas Kronwall has gotten onto the ice behind the play. Porter crosses the line, drops it to Crombeen, and heads to the front. Kronwall releases Porter behind him as he tries to react to the rush, but he can't prevent the cross-ice pass to Nichol, who has the wide-open net to shoot at and doesn't fail. I feel so badly for Kronwall here that I'm going to halve his minus. I'm not sure I can really blame a guy for not stopping this play as it developed, but he can't get completely cleared. Emmerton will have his minus cleared for having just stepped on the ice and Drew Miller will get his minus back and will earn another for a bad decision to change. Lidstrom will actually keep his minus here. I feel he's pretty slow to get off the bench and into the play. Ericsson will earn his minus back as he's the far-side defenseman whose job it is to make sure he's not stepping off the ice without the puck getting all the way down. Cleary and Abdelkader both keep their minuses. [Update: Based on the comments below and another look at this situation, this is a time when I honestly have no idea which guy messed up here. I'd have to hear from Babcock himself or one of the players before I could adequately assign blame on this line change. Neither Lidstrom nor Ericsson will keep a minus]
2nd Period 00:51 - Detroit Goal (PP): Pavel Datsyuk (backhand) from Nicklas Lidstrom and Henrik Zetterberg
The Penalty - Christ Stewart (instigator): Brad Stuart nails Alex Pietrangelo and Stewart the meathead decides he has to answer for a clean hit. Both players get fighting majors, but Stewart gets the instigator. I love the hit by our defenseman, bu tit's up to the idiot in the Blues jersey not to instigate. No adjustment.
Detroit ties it up on a great individual effort. The period almost starts out disastrous as the patented neutral zone drop-pass from Lidstrom to Datsyuk doesn't connect and nearly leads to a David Perron breakaway were it not for Henrik Zetterberg skating back hard to neutralize the chance. Detroit gets their collective shit together from there and enters the zone. Detroit sets up in their typical umbrella formation and gets a good look on the near-side as Lidstrom puts a slap-pass on Pavel Datsyuk's stick for a redirect attempt that goes just wide. Zetterberg picks it up on the other side and skates up the boards to overload the left. He gets to the half-boards before going back to Datsyuk in the corner. Pavs is chased out by Pietrangelo, so he passes to Lidstrom at the point. Nick draws in Perron before going back to Datsyuk now at the half-boards. Datsyuk turns at the top of the circle to face the net while Zetterberg hangs out in the high slot and Holmstrom stays net-front. Pietrangelo is a little low in the zone, which gives Datsyuk room to turn and face him. Pavel fakes to the forehand, causing Pietrangelo to bite and take a knee for the supposed shot block. This gives Datsyuk the space he needs to bring it into the slot and fire a backhand pass top shelf on Halak before Backes can slide off the coverage of Zetterberg to stop him. I'm going to give Zetterberg a plus for getting back on Perron to prevent the shorthanded goal and also give both Datsyuk and Lidstrom a half-minus for that turnover. On the good side of things, I feel Lidstrom and Datsyuk both deserve half-assists for quarterbacking this power play all the way after it gets set up. Holmstrom will absolutely get the screener's assist, as he forces Halak to lean the entire way to give Datsyuk room.
Penalty Adjustment: 2:54 into the 2nd, Detroit gets whistled for a penalty, as the Blues' forecheck creates turnover in the Wings' end. Backes gets his stick on a Mike Commodore clear, which leaves the puck in the zone. Pietrangelo steps up to poke it back to Backes, who finds Perron cutting back through the middle. Perron makes a move on Lidstrom 1-on-1 and Lidstrom gets his stick into the midsection to take a hooking penalty. Lidstrom will get a minus for taking the penalty, but Commodore will also get one for his failure to clear the zone. I think Commodore made a high-risk play while his team was setting up for the safer play. However, Drew Miller is part of what lets Perron come in on Lidstrom 1-on-1. Miller will also get a half-minus.
2nd Period 08:52 - Detroit Goal: Johan Franzen (backhand) from Jonathan Ericsson and Todd Bertuzzi
Detroit gets the eventual game-winner off an offensive zone faceoff win. Datsyuk sweeps the faceoff back to Ericsson, who backs to the point and throws it up the boards. Datsyuk tips it on its way to the corner and Bertuzzi is first on it with Colaiacovo in tow. An amazing thing happens here after the dump-in by Ericcson, he actually jumps up in a play. Bertuzzi throws him a backhanded pass from the corner and he one-times a wrister from just above the faceoff circles in the middle. The puck hits the Franzen/Pietrangelo traffic in front and sits there. From that point, it's on Johan Franzen to outmuscle Alex Pietrangelo for the rebound and make a wide turn to backhand it around Halak's skate. Datsyuk will earn the third assist on this play.
Penalty Adjustment: Midway through the third period, Detroit almost gets their insurance goal early on a great in-zone steal by Valtteri Filppula. Flip intercepts an outlet pass from Colaiacovo and gets hooked on his way to dishing it off to Hudler. Filppula will earn a plus.
3rd Period 16:57 - Detroit Goal (PP): Niklas Kronwall (slap shot) from Nicklas Lidstrom and Pavel Datsyuk
The Penalty - Carlo Colaiacovo (roughing): Colaiacovo completely loses his marbles when Darren Helm forechecks aggressively and knocks Alex Pietrangelo on his ass while they race for a loose puck behind the net. This is excellent poise and patience by Helm to not only lay a clean hit, but also to keep his cool in avoiding taking what would have been a very easy even-up call for the refs. Helm will get a plus.
Niklas Kronwall throws a dagger straight into the heart of the Blues with the Wings' second power play goal of the night. The Blues get a clear on the 4-on-3 power play and force Detroit to regroup and re-enter the zone. Datsyuk accomplishes this with ease as the Wings establish their presence and spread out. Pavel takes the low corner with Lidstrom above him at the point, Holmstrom in front of the net, and Kronwall at the other point (which is in the middle of the ice with their setup). Pavs and Lids play catch on the boards before Lidstrom brings it out over to Kronwall and the movement they force has the points collapsed to the top of the circle. Kronwall goes back to Lidstrom for a fake one-timer that he passes right back. By now, the Blues have collapses into a one-low, two-high formation, but that doesn't help them when Kronwall gets his slapshot through the legs of Jackman, past the screen of Holmstrom, and into the net past Halak. This is good movement on the play, but the only adjustment will be to add another screener's assist to Holmstrom.
Penalty Non-Adjustments
2nd Period 11:07 - Jamie Langenbrunner (slashing): This is actually the second time a Wings player gets his stick slashed out of his hands, but the first one that's called. It's not a drawn penalty though.
3rd Period 14:54 - Todd Bertuzzi & David Backes (roughing): Backes is acting like a dick here, but apparently the refs can't just put him in a timeout without also taking that mean old Todd Bertuzzi. Whatever. No adjustment.
3rd Period 19:56 - David Backes, Alex Pietrangelo, & Jimmy Howard (roughing, misconduct, roughing, misconduct, roughing): HAHAHA JIMMY HOWARD OWNS YOU. No seriously though, the Blues got cheap. Howard's a damn hero for protecting his own crease, but it's kind of pointless to give him a plus here, even if I totally want to.
Bonus Ratings
+1 to Brad Stuart & Niklas Kronwall: The Wings' second pair played as well as you'd want out of a first-pairing group. Stuart's hit on Pietrangelo and his follow-up physical engagement was a key part in the Blues eventually losing their collective shit. Kronwall was a bit unsure at times in his own zone, but he stayed solid and was a big part in driving transition.
+1.5 to Nicklas Lidstrom: Lidstrom had his game working on all cylinders. He kept second-chance attempts from getting on net and prevented three clearing attempts at even strength. He was a huge reason the Blues' most dangerous forwards were kept off the scoresheet.
+2 to Darren Helm, Danny Cleary, & Drew Miller: I thought this line was the most-consistent line of the night at putting good pressure on the Blues in their own zone and keeping the puck out of Detroit's end. The shooting stats bear this out, as combining the shots for/against for these three was 27-5. I can't state how important I felt this line was to earning and maintaining the momentum in this game.
+1 to Henrik Zetterberg and Valtteri Filppula: These two did most of the heavy lifting against the Blues' top line (nothing against Hudler, who also played well, but he just wasn't as involved & didn't need to be). I love the defensive coverage these two provide together.
+0.5 to Pavel Datsyuk, Todd Bertuzzi, & Johan Franzen: I really liked how physically engaged this entire line was. They were only credited for six hits between them, but I felt that they consistently chose to play bodies instead of pucks and that slowed the Blues down a lot.
+1 to Justin Abdelkader: Abby dished out five hits, recorded two takeaways, won 4 of 6 faceoffs and otherwise left his mark on a game in which he played fewer than eight minutes. That's not easy to do.
Honorable Mentions:
Both Ian White and Jonathan Ericsson had a couple of turnovers which turned what would have been pluses into mere honorable mentions. I liked how quietly solid Commodore was as well. Emmerton and Holmstrom played well in their limited minutes, and Hudler was good. Ultimately, aside from the one bad change, I thought the Wings played well even when the Blues were controlling momentum.
Click on a column header to sort by that stat. Shift+click will create secondary sorts.
Use the drop-down at the top to toggle between points adjustments, plus/minus adjustments, and goalie adjustments
Be sure to check out HockeyCSSI.com for even more.
34 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
JIMMAH
While I don’t want him to get hurt, I love that Howard is not afraid to mix things up.
He was an absolute beast tonight.
I agree wholeheartedly on the 3rd line
Helm/Cleary/Miller had a hell of a game, even though I think Cleary had a few weak plays throughout.
On an unrelated note, I’m glad we were able to keep local coverage instead of being subjected to NBC sportscasting. Versus instead showed the TSN feed of the Carolina/Winnipeg game, and I swear Staal is trying his best to look invisible
3rd Line
I agree completely as well. I feel like in the last few games, the 3rd line has been the reason that the Wings keep winning. Now they just need to put the puck in the net. Their great shift led to the offensive zone face off that lead to the Franzen goal and Helm’s great fore-checking set up the power play goal by Kronwall. Helm’s my second favorite Wing for a reason and I love that he’s been throwing the body around lately.
by GoBigBlueDud on Jan 24, 2012 12:20 AM CST up reply actions
Cleary has been pretty bad offensively for the last several games. He just can’t seem to finish around the net. He had a great chance last night and just didn’t elevate it over Halak’s pad. That line really is playing great defensively. Our depth scoring always seems to heat up whenever the big guys slow down (which certainly isn’t the case right now).
Langenbrunner Slashing Call
Man, I dont know why but the guys I was watching the game with at the bar and I all started laughing hysterically when Ian White’s stick went flying.
White just kind of stood there, shrugged, and then looked at the guy like “wtf man”. I guess it was that and that the stick went flying 300 feet into the air like Langenbrunner took it from him and threw it like a pissed off older brother or something.
On a side note I have to give the boys in red sweaters a HUGE pat on the back for playing such an awesomely physical game tonight and still keeping the penalties under control.
Ken Daniels said something weird today
After Datsyuk ran into the boards and kncoed his helmet off:
“Pavel Datsyuk just found out what it’s like to end up on Ford Street by accident!”
What the hell is he talking about?
"I believe in a good kick in the ass. This— I believe. " -- Walker Percy
I tweet about stuff sometimes @jackhitts.
OK, actually I think it was Mickey and not Ken
But still. I don’t get it.
"I believe in a good kick in the ass. This— I believe. " -- Walker Percy
I tweet about stuff sometimes @jackhitts.
Fort street is a couple blocks from the Joe
When Pavel went flying into the boards he had so much momentum Mickey jokingly said he could have found himself on Fort Street if not for the boards.
"More giveaways than the Salvation Army" - Mickey Redmond
by krett on Jan 24, 2012 1:19 AM CST via Android app up reply actions
Yeah, that makes sense now
I don’t live in Detroit anymore so I forget some of the geography sometimes.
But I thought he was trying to say that’s what happens when you go to Ford Street You get your ass kicked… or something. It was goofy. I laughed out loud.
"I believe in a good kick in the ass. This— I believe. " -- Walker Percy
I tweet about stuff sometimes @jackhitts.
If the 3rd line could figure out how to score goals...
they’d probably be the best line we have, at least in terms of the scoring chances they find themselves in. but i might be overwhelming blinded by adoration for darren helm.
"I'll smile in June."
by Lords of Olympia on Jan 24, 2012 1:40 AM CST reply actions
otherwise, you've got this game pretty much down pat
i couldn’t figure out who gets the proper minus on the line change mishap.
glad to know it’s kronner.
ericsson really didn’t seem out of place, if maybe little outplayed.
"I'll smile in June."
by Lords of Olympia on Jan 24, 2012 1:43 AM CST up reply actions
also, also
darren helm’s current adjusted CSSI +/- is 43.
awesome.
"I'll smile in June."
by Lords of Olympia on Jan 24, 2012 4:09 AM CST up reply actions
stewart misconduct
im still kind of confused why Chris Stewart (not OUR Stuart) got the misconduct for the fight? He got the fighting major and the instigator, which seems pretty fair. His team was penalized and so was he.
Its probably just up to the official, but is there some rule im missing here?
I think
it was because he left the bench with the sole intent of starting a fight (no attempt to join the play on ice, play the puck, etc)
by Red, White and a Mile high on Jan 24, 2012 7:54 AM CST up reply actions
It's either that
or he mouthed off to the ref once he was told he was getting the instigator.
by J.J. from Kansas on Jan 24, 2012 8:01 AM CST up reply actions
Per the Instigator Rule
A player who is deemed to be the instigator of an altercation shall be assessed an instigating minor penalty, a major penalty for fighting and a ten-minute misconduct.
Dancing Datsyuk Decidedly Dazzles Dainty Defensemen
by Robocop on Jan 24, 2012 8:05 AM CST up reply actions 2 recs
Is that something that the League reviews as well?
I thought I heard the guys on Vs/NBCSN say something like that last night.
Speaking of the broadcast, Dave Strader is so much easier to deal with than Mike Emrick, plus there was no Edzo, we did have Lil’ Baldy to listen to, but thankfully, no one else….Babcock’s interview during the 1st was hilarious – he was so pissed, it was great. And he talked enough that Pierre hardly got a word in….even better.
Is that Jimmy's best game rating to date?
He was awesome tonight, so he totally deserves it.
I'm a Homer
I Lidstrom is probably not deserving of the minus on that goal. From what they said in the broadcast, Ericsson and Stewart shouldn’t have been changing at the same time. I don’t know who was supposed to be coming over with Kronwall, but I’m guessing it wasn’t Nick, since he doesn’t play with Kronwall, and doesn’t play the right side. It seemed like the bench was confused by the change, and Lidstrom may have just been the first one to hop over when he realized that no one was changing and we were giving up a 3 on 1.
Kronwall also was completely left out to dry by everyone on the team. He was the only one who changed on time, and got to defend a 3 on 1 for his trouble.
The only person who clearly screwed up, IMO, was whatever forward failed to get the puck in deep.
The failing forward
was both Drew Miller and Justin Abdelkader, who got their minuses.
I need to look more into it, but you may be right about Lidstrom and that may be exactly why he came off the bench at all, because he realized one of his teammates missed his change. It would seem to make sense because, even with the defensive pairings mixed up last night, I don’t think Lidstrom and Kronwall was one of those mixtures. I believe it was Commodore playing on a pair with Kronwall at that point, right?
I’ll go back later tonight and re-check the shift charts. If it’s the case where Lidstrom is covering for a teammate’s missed change, I’ll be sure to take away his minus and give that teammate one instead.
I’m also pretty sure that Ericsson changed for Kronwall, who did get onto the ice in time to cover. If that’s the case, then we need to decide whether he should indeed get a minus for a bad change when it turns out that his was the only actual “good” change.
by J.J. from Kansas on Jan 24, 2012 9:48 AM CST up reply actions
D-pairs
were way off when Stuie was out for his fighting major, but other than that, I didn’t notice too many weird combinations.
I remember
being glad when the whistle blew at 15:00 of the 2nd, because that meant Stuie was back and the D-Pairs were back to normal.
Lidstrom may have just been the first one to hop over when he realized that no one was changing and we were giving up a 3 on 1.
I was wondering the same thing, although I don’t remember the D pairings for the shifts immediately prior. Glad it came up anyway.
Looking at the shift charts
I’ve got two options for what to do with that minus: I can either let Lidstrom have it or let nobody have it.
The D-Pairs hadn’t been messed with by then. Ericsson was finishing a pretty long shift (and will have that minus I gave him cleared). Commodore had already changed for Stuart previously, which left Stuart out there. Ericsson changed for Kronwall (who was still Stuart’s partner at the time), but Stuart had already been out there for a fairly decent chunk himself.
Honestly, there’s no way to tell who messed this one up. Either Ericsson shouldn’t have changed, turning a more-than-a-minute-long shift into an even longer one; Stuart shouldn’t have changed, creating a long shift for himsef; Commodore should have come back out, after a a 30-second rest from his previous shift; or White or Lidstrom should have come out to play against the Blues’ fourth line.
Ultimately, I think I’m going to clear the minuses for Lidstrom and Ericsson and put this fuck-up on the bench boss who let it happen. I really have no idea which defenseman should have come out in that situation. If I absolutely HAD to assign blame, I would say that Stuart shouldn’t have changed.
I’ll listen to arguments all ways though. Let me know what you think
by J.J. from Kansas on Jan 24, 2012 4:29 PM CST up reply actions
I think the far side D-man (Stu?) gets some of the blame for not at least keeping an eye out for turnover headed back before completing the change , but if the shift is already painfully long then that’s a pretty tough call.
Regardless, the bench has to be ready. Without knowing for sure who was supposed to come over the boards on that shift, blaming it on Babs is probably as fair as we’re gonna get.
Do you think Stu deserves a half-minus?
by J.J. from Kansas on Jan 24, 2012 5:47 PM CST up reply actions
Finally found that behind the net replay that actually shows everyone’s position. I was wrong, it was Miller who had the far boards and went for the change well behind the D-men (both of which I think were clear to change in this situation). I’d give Miller a minus beyond the official one for that change. He wasn’t paying any attention to the play or the lack of D-men after dumping it out of the zone.
As for the botched change, looks like there were only 4 wings on the ice when the goal was scored and 2 or 3 guys were still straddling the boards, so definitely some bench blame there too.
Fair enough
I’ll add it
Thank you for your help.
by J.J. from Kansas on Jan 24, 2012 6:47 PM CST up reply actions

by 















